The Sum of Pakistani Wishes by Lt Gen P R Shankar (R)

They say  ‘Be careful of what you wish for. It might come true’! Pakistan keeps boasting that it had defeated a superpower – USSR. Now it is loud mouthing that it is defeating another superpower- USA. Technically, the speed of Taliban advance and the rate of withdrawal from Afghanistan marks it as a US defeat. Pakistan’s wishes are probably coming true. Has Pakistan won again? USA and Pakistan were supposed to be on one side. However, Pakistan and Taliban were also on one side. As are Pakistan and China. Pakistan always defeats its friends to stay relevant. Is it the shape of things to come in future? In defeating USA, has Pakistan defeated itself? As long as USA was around in the area and Taliban were negotiating, Pakistan and China were on free ride. With USA stepping out of the scene, and Taliban making rapid advances into power, things have come to a head. Everyone is scrambling for cover including Taliban. Most of all it is Pakistan which is running around since something more  than its great wish is coming true.       


It is quite clear that Afghanistan is sliding into chaos. Two outcomes are possible and evident. A power sharing agreement can come about. It will result in a shaky governing structure dotted with violence and clashes instigated largely by the Taliban. Taliban will continually try to wield the upper hand in the structure with Pakistani assistance. The other alternative is a Taliban ruled Afghanistan. This option runs the risk of lacking international recognition and funding. This option will also take Afghanistan back to the medieval ages. However in this article, we will focus on Pakistan and see what is in store for it. I would like to highlight that these are not a figment of my fertile imagination but what I have culled from Pakistani writings. Not a single day goes by when some intelligent Pakistani writer does not underscore what I have written here in an op-ed with far greater eloquence than mine.      


Pakistan’s official stance is that it wants a peaceful outcome in Afghanistan, where a power-sharing arrangement is reached between the Taliban and the current Afghan dispensation. However very few believe it. Afterall, Pakistan was the main architect of the  Taliban regime in Afghanistan in the 1990s. Pakistan gave sanctuary, medical and all kinds of help to Taliban and Al Qaeda in its cities. Even now Taliban leaders and Shuras operate out of Pakistani cities. Their fighters are being treated in Pakistani hospitals. Their families live in Pakistan. The general impression and truth is that Pakistan backs Taliban and wants to  hoist it in power in Kabul in a sham of a brokered agreement. As the Taliban gains ground rapidly, the needle of suspicion points squarely toward Pakistan. Let us be clear, without Pakistani support, Taliban cannot survive.  


What did Pakistan wish for ? Pakistan has always wished to control Afghanistan as its surrogate state under a client Taliban regime. Afghanistan had to be hostile to India. It would give the Pakistani ‘Deep State’ a secure western border and strategic depth in its eternal war of unattainable revenge on India. Surrogacy is feasible only if the regime was controllable. As long as USA was in Afghanistan, there was no question of any regime or any kind of control. Hence the long term plan was to continually undermine the USA till it exits Afghanistan. Build itself a reputation as a nation which has defeated two superpowers. China could then be brought into the picture to replace USA. This was to be done through hybrid and gray zone methods by using its home grown fighters and free floating jihadists of LeT and JeM and other motely organisations to assist Taliban. This plan is now being executed. However, the question is where is this road show heading? 


We have to step on to the Durand Line to understand the future. On the Pakistan side of the Durand Line lie the provinces of Balochistan, NWFP, and the seven tribal agencies of the FATA ( now Khyber Paktunwa). On the Afghan side is a large swathe of Pashtun area. The Durand Line, divides the Pashtun and Baloch tribal areas which straddle Afghanistan and Pakistan. The tribal agencies of FATA had a border further East, with the erstwhile British administration which Pakistan inherited. The area between the two borders was largely left loose for the Pashtuns to govern themselves. FATA and the border belt was some sort of an uncharted territory. This area always had an incipient Pashtun and Baloch nationalistic fervour. The Durand Line was never recognised in letter or spirit by any tribal.


Fast forward to the 80s.  Zia ul-Haq promoted  jihad, funded thousands of Islamic madrassas and armed domestic Islamist organizations in the Af Pak border region.  Funding was from CIA  to raise and support Mujahideen. In doing so, he also sought to supress any local tribal nationalism on the Pakistani side of the Durand Line. The Islamist Mujahideen, drawn from the Pashtun and Baloch themselves, were the instrument to blunt and subsume local  separatist tendencies. In this endeavour, the Afghan Taliban became Pakistan’s proteges. Pakistan promoted the Taliban ideology and scotched Pashtun nationalist sentiment. In the entire process spanning four decades, Pakistan created a militarized and radicalized Af Pak border. This happened in an area where people do not respect nationalities but tribal loyalties. It is in this cauldron that Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) was born with the aim of creating a sharia driven Pakistan. Alongside this, Baloch rebels also took to militancy and violence. Pakistan succeeded in creating its own transborder devils.


What does Pakistan get hereafter? Pakistan wished USA away. That wish has been fulfilled. In addition, Pakistan gets three things. First, fighting in Afghanistan spilling over into Pakistan.  Second, refugee inflow into Pakistan which it can’t afford. Third, resurgence of the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), a group which is capable of  attacking the country’s army, security forces, and politicians to destabilise the country. Each of these need deeper understanding. 


Insecurity spilling over into Pakistan is a given. Already there has been some cross border firing in which Pakistani soldiers have been injured. Going ahead,  will the insecurity be in the form of fighting between the warring factions in Afghanistan alone? I think it might be beyond that. USA’s withdrawal from Afghanistan makes it ‘weapons free’. USA does not have to fight with one hand tied behind its back anymore. The greater threat which it now faces is possible military action in case USA feels that Pakistan is stepping out of line or being duplicitous beyond acceptable limits. Punitive military action by USA in the guise of accidental fratricide cannot be ruled out! There is already precedence to such action. The Pakis will be fully alive to the incident when a Pakistani post was vaporised.  Further, too many people have engaged with Pakistan and have been bitten by it. It might be payback time.    


Refugee influx into Pakistan is waiting to happen. A bankrupt Pakistan cannot afford them. Pakistani duplicity will ensure that there is minimum appetite to support it. Afterall it is pandemic time. Without the support of USA, international agencies will not come forward even for humanitarian assistance beyond a point. Pakistan’s efforts to get China into pole position will further inhibit everyone from helping Pakistan. All these refugees will end up creating social, economic and security problems in the long run. That is inevitable.  


However, the most pressing issue is TTP. Understanding this phenomenon needs another detour. Afghanistan is the world’s largest cultivator and supplier of opium (93 % of the global opiates market). The opium economy has grown tenfold in the past three decades. Pashtuns and Balochis earn a lot from cross-border smuggling in drugs, arms, and even people.  The porous border and similar tribal ethnicities straddling the Durand Line have made it a lucrative occupation on both sides. The transborder political and quasi military networks straddling the Durand Line are integrated and self-sustaining economically. They also provide external support to each other. The external support factor is primal to sustain any insurgency. The Afghan Taliban and TTP are ideological twins and are intertwined in their enterprises through tribal loyalties which are beyond any nation state concept.  They are part of one interconnected network. Both are trained by Pakistan in the same madrassas. Both are fired by the same radicalistic motivation.  In fact, the Pakistani ‘Deep State’ which had a significant share of the transit trade economic pie will now be culled. With USA leaving this area, the coffers of the  Pakistani ‘Deep State’ will  start to run dry. Those of the Talibans’ will not. The TTP has started resurfacing in a big way.


The TTP chief Noor Wali Mehsud recently stated in an  interview with CNN that TTP  aims  for independence of tribal districts of Pakistan. This is a shift from its earlier focus of imposing Sharia and overthrowing the Government of Pakistan. The Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement would have taught it that a nationalist agenda is popular among the masses. It is also assessed that TTP may propagate  nationalist rhetoric to gain political legitimacy among the tribes. The apprehension is that a TTP focused exclusively on the tribal areas will be  a stronger force to handle. As the Afghan Taliban  gain ground in Afghanistan, TTP will be further emboldened and strengthened. PTM is thus far a political movement without violence. If TTP and PTM  joins hands the potential to  pose an existential threat to Pakistan is very very high. Both are Pashtun organisations. It is a tinderbox!  There is also speculation that Pakistan could cut a deal with the Afghan Taliban to constrain the TTP. How effective it would be is a question mark. Tribal loyalties are always stronger than national sentiments. 


There is another phenomenon expected. Radicals of all shades, will also seek inspiration from the Afghan Taliban’s ‘victories’ and could gravitate to TTP. Disillusioned  youth and underemployed cadres  of JuD and JeM could be attracted like moth to a flame. So far they are with the Afghan Taliban. They could be repurposed to the TTP. We should not forget the IS and Al Qaeda are still in the frame. All these organisations might be separate but its foot soldiers are fungible. Add the banned Tehreek-i-Labbaik, Pakistan. Add  persecuted Shia organisations. Add the ongoing  Baloch rebellion. The mix is indeed heavy. The tenuous relationship between the state, society and religion in Pakistan will get further blurred. This much is evident in the increase in attacks on security forces and Chinese personnel. The latest bomb blast in Quetta at the Serena Hotel enlarges the scope. 


There is another reality beyond all this. The world knows that Taliban is a product of Pakistani double game. Everyone also knows that the problem is really Pakistan and not Afghanistan. In a larger sense, the game is about money. That is why, Pakistan is running to USA to cut a deal. In Washington, there was always a clarity that  Pakistan was playing both sides. However with boots on ground, USA could do very little about it. Now that the boots are out, USA seems to have changed track fully. Pakistani boasts of defeating a superpower will only fuel US rage. That is why USA has already started to give a cold shoulder to Pakistan. This time around, USA might not go overt. It need not. Pakistan is a bankrupt tinderbox. China is a competitor. Both are ‘iron’ brothers.  Both have aspirations which the West is apprehensive about. USA is a past master at the covert. The new great game might just be unfolding in Pakistan. Afghanistan might just be the prelude. India should know which wicket to bat on and how! Pakistan can keep wishing that President Biden will give a call to Taliban Khan! Let the game begin! 


7 responses to “The Sum of Pakistani Wishes by Lt Gen P R Shankar (R)”

  1. Salute Lt. General Ravi Shankar. Sir “India should know which wicket to bat on and how” is the bottom-line. Not easy by any means. Hope we take a right decision

  2. Very nice piece. My compliments

  3. Excellent PRS. As usual well analysed, with relevant details, article.

  4. SirPakistan has has played double game & created conditions for defeat of partner USA while on the other hand has cheated innocent Afghan fighters by allowing US basis He has used selfish Taliban leaders and sacrificed ordinary Taliban fighters

  5. Don't you observe many parallels between this situation and India's misadventures with the LTTE in Sri Lanka in the late 80s? Homogenous orgs with their own independant agendas can never be controlled beyond a point by the nation states which spawn them, they merely switch sponsors to further their own agenda.

  6. Enjoyed reading the detailed analysis on the unfolding great game. Well written indeed.Compliments General.

  7. The author missed one important point is how China will be forced by Pakistan to cooperate with. China, like how USA was depending on Pakistan for land access to Afghanistan, is in lock-step with Pakistan because of CPEC and Afghan carrot. China is trapped and will be forced to fund Pakistan and ignore her misadventures in India.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: