An Interview With Rediff.Com on Yangtse Faceoff

‘India is China’s prime military target’

December 22, 2022 09:54 IST

‘On the LAC, China can undertake military action at any place with much fewer resources. It can do ‘salami slicing’.’

“If China enters Taiwan, there’s a chance it might get entangled with the USA, Japan, the Philippines, South Korea, etc. It has no exit option once it crosses the Taiwan Strait,” says Lieutenant General P R Shankar (retired) former director general of artillery and professor, aerospace department, IIT-Madras.

What are some of the lessons and new challenges that emanate from the face-off at Yangste in Arunachal Pradesh?

If you look into the Sino-Indian history of conflict, the number of face-offs and incursions have increased dramatically since Xi Jinping assumed power in 2012. There have also been a phenomenal number of summits and other meetings between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Xi Jinping. The two have met 18-19 times since 2014. A major part of these summits and meetings have been about keeping peace on the border between India and China, but yet the opposite has happened. Almost every summit or every important meeting between India and China has seen a faceoff or transgression going back to April 2013 when the incident at Depsang happened ahead of Chinese Premier Li Keqiang’s visit. In 2017 when Xi and Modi met in Ahmedabad, there was a Chinese incursion happening in Chumar. Hence, chronologically, almost every meeting has been preceded or succeeded by transgression. All these incidents are a well-planned Chinese strategy; they are not ad hoc. Recently, Modi and Xi met after two years at the G20 meet and within one month there was another face-off. Therefore, there is a lesson in this pattern which shows that China will talk to you, but will do exactly the opposite.

The Communist party congress in October asserted that Chinese territory must be assimilated with the People’s Republic of China. After Taiwan, will China target Arunachal Pradesh which it calls ‘South Tibet’?

The widely held view is that China’s main focus is Taiwan. Everyone talks about China’s design of going into Taiwan and capturing it militarily, but China has not done any such action. So, the question is whether it is India or is it Taiwan that is China’s prime military target? According to me, India is the prime military target because the empirical evidence, historical evidence and the actual ground situation point in that direction — and we need to be prepared accordingly. Going ahead, we need to enhance our preparedness in the light of China’s stagnating/declining economy and another surge of the Covid pandemic. There are already many articles in the international press about China becoming a declining power — and one must remember that a declining power is always dangerous. China’s target is India and hence, we must be prepared. If you take the larger perspective, China has two politico-military problems — India and Taiwan. Taiwan is a high risk operation where China may or may not succeed. Moreover, China is still not prepared to undertake this action as of now. If China enters Taiwan, there’s a chance it might get entangled with the USA, Japan, the Philippines, South Korea, etc and hence there’s no exit option once it crosses the Taiwan Strait. Whereas on the Line of Actual Control, China can undertake military action at any place with much fewer resources. It can do ‘salami slicing’ and undertake other activities. The 3,500 kms long LAC provides more opportunities to carry out their designs. They can start with small pockets and enlarge the areas of conflict. It also provides them with an exit option for every action — they can always go back to its people and say they were just defending the area claimed by them which the Indians have transgressed. This is also the narrative that is coming out of China. So we have to be alert to this fact and prepare accordingly in view of this background.

A face-off happened in Arunachal Pradesh last year. Are we going to see repeats of such face-offs and incursions on a more sustained basis?

There are going to be more problems, maybe at different places, at different times and different vectors. We don’t know what kind of incidents, but they will be there. In that case we need to have our modernisation, theatrisation and jointness plan in place that was envisaged when the chief of defence staff was appointed. The big question is whether all this is going as scheduled. All this needs a revisit and rethink in light of the Chinese actions. Another question that arises from the face-off in Yangtse is about the Agniveer policy. I would be interested in knowing how many of the jawans who took part in this operation had less than four years of service. What will happen tomorrow when the number of Agniveers on such pickets goes up? Will Agniveers with four years of service be able to deliver the results which our jawans have delivered in Yangtse? We should ask the company commanders and battalion commanders on the spot if they would have been comfortable with Agniveers under their command in that face-off. There are reports coming from China and in the international media about the poor morale and inexperience of the PLA troops. In fact, there was an article in the New Yorker and in the South China Morning Postabout the prevalence of mental illness amongst PLA troops. Ultimately, at those heights, it is the troops that matter the most. Today, we have this great advantage of an experienced Indian Army vis a vis an inexperienced or under confident PLA. In time to come, what will be the results when we deploy Agniveers in these areas? In that light, is there a need to modify the Agniveer programme? These are some of the lessons that we must bear in mind.

Part 2 will be published later by


7 responses to “An Interview With Rediff.Com on Yangtse Faceoff”

  1. Surendra Barsode Avatar

    Agniweer is a well thought out scheme recently implemented under which at least 25% of the suitable recruits will be absorbed in the regular cadre and the rest will be sent out. So as of now, Army is still full of regulars and it is only over a period of next few years that we will have preponderance of Agniveers. We ought to evaluate the scheme and make changes as required, as we gather experience. Let us not write off as of now!!

    1. Its not about josh. Its about hardened and seasoned soldiers. Agniveers will not be able to manage this kind of affair. It takes 4 to 5 years to harden a guy, its also about decision making and instinctive action. Cant be expected out of a 4 year soldier. We who have been there know it and are the best judges.

      1. Especially considering that in the 4th year the Agniveers will be pre-occupied with returning to civilian life after completion of their term. This will surely have some effect on their mental preparedness to go above & beyond.

      2. Sir, i agree with you that it takes years to be a hardened soldiers and we need many of them as well. Assuming Agniveer is in place, at least 25 per cent of them will be absorbed in regular cadre to be the hardened ones. And that should be enough in terms of optimising cost and resources along with latest technologies. After all, Agniveer scheme is drafted by some of the hardened soldiers like you and we civilians are impressed with it. In fact, like Agniveers we would like to have a Sevak scheme !! At least you can boot out corrupt n incompetent from civil services soon enough!! So let’s us give it try and see if it works. If not, we can always go back to the BAU or increase the ratio to say, 50 percent etc.

  2. Agree with Surinder Barsode’s comments.

  3. […] An Interview With Rediff.Com on Yangtse Faceoff The Larger Chinese Strategy in Tawang L’Affaire Tawang Beyond The Tawang Incident : A Discussion […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: